Thursday, October 25, 2012

Bad GUI: Madden NFL 12 (iPhone)


            I will be discussing the bad game interface designs for Madden NFL 12 for smart phones. Madden NFL 12 is a sports touch football smart phone game. The player can choose what teams they would like to play with in different modes. The player only needs one finger to play this game. There isn’t anything very innovative about Madden NFL 12, considering it looks like Madden ’98 with new players.

1. When first starting the app, there are four options plus some other buttons. There is a football players picture that usually s it difficult for the text to be read. Also in the bottom of the screen there are a few buttons that make the screen have a cluttered feeling, and there are logos to add to it. It can also be difficult to touch the right menu if you have bigger fingers.






2. Once the player chooses the Play Now, the screen displays two teams that you can chooses from, Settings, Back and Play buttons at the bottom. The buttons can be very difficult to push and sometimes the game won’t register when you want to change teams.



3. If a player wants to trade players, they will have to use this screen, which is actually terrible. Every part of the screen that you can select is way to close to each other. I understand that the screen is very small and it is hard to make an interface that is effective, but maybe the developers could have used larger buttons and pages. And again the buttons at the bottom are difficult to press.



4. While actually playing the game, it is very difficult to pass the ball. When the player starts a pass play, red, yellow and green boxes, which are very close together, represent the available players that can catch a pass. This makes it very difficult to pick the right player that you want when throwing the ball.



Thank for your reading my post and I look forward to answering any questions or responses.

Daniel Weimer

No comments:

Post a Comment